About the Post

Author Information

Camera allegedly showing the North Pole melting turns out to be approximately 300 miles to the South

Everybody’s seen this picture the last few days supposedly showing that the North Pole is melting.

Turns out, that camera is on a buoy that has drifted approximately 300 miles to the south and is now closer to Greenland than the North Pole.

Just found this interesting tidbit on Accuweather.com from the States.”from Roger Anderson, who is one of the webcam scientists at the Universtiy of Washington. I had asked him if the media was using the webcams that were NOT at the North Pole, but rather drifting southward (to show the North Pole is melting).

He replied: “Yes, they are. The approximate position of the webcams today (obtained from PAWS Buoy 819920) is 07/25/1500Z 84.773°N 5.415°W.” This is even further south than I had placed the buoy, because the data I had was one week old. This puts the webcam at approximately 350 miles south of the North Pole.

IMPORTANT UPDATE 7/26: I was not able to add this information to the top of my blog, due to a technical error. Here is a response I received via email from the webcam scientists, confirming the melting was NOT attributable to global warming: QUOTE:

“Given the excitement over recent images, we are putting the following write up with the images on our web site.

Thanks for your interest,

Jamie Morison.

Melt Ponds
We have received numerous requests for information on the Web Camera # 2 images showing the development of a significant melt pond around the camera. The formation of melt ponds has always been a key feature of the summer season on sea ice. Each summer, solar radiation melts the snow cover and 10-50 cm of the sea ice upper surface. Depending on the porosity of the sea ice, the number of cracks, and distribution of openings at the edge of individual ice floes, some of the melt water from the surface drains to the ocean and the rest forms melt ponds. These are fresh water ponds lying on top of the sea ice with their surfaces slightly above sea level.

The Web Cameras.
Web Camera #1 is a system built and deployed by the Polar Science Center in April 2012 at the Barneo ice camp approximately 25 miles from the North Pole as part of the NSF-funded North Pole Environmental Observatory (NPEO). It is meant to give a visual record of ice changes over the spring-summer-fall season. Ablation stakes made of plywood strips 10-cm wide and marked with alternating black and white 10-cm squares are planted in the ice near the buoy to indicate visually the amount of surface melting as the summer proceeds. Also in the field of view of this camera are an Ice-T buoy built by Frederic Vivier of Le Laboratoire Ocean Université Pierre et Marie Curie (UPMC) to measure bottom melt and heat conduction through the ice and a Polar Ocean Profiling System (POPS) installed by Takashi Kikuchi of JAMSTEC to measure temperature and salinity profiles in the top 1000 m of the ocean. The camera is about 1.5 m above the April ice surface. The Ice-T buoy is 12-14 m away from the camera and the POPs buoy is about 53 m away.

Web Camera #2 was built by the Polar Science Center with the support of Jean-Claude Gascard of UPMC. It was installed and its data are recovered by NPEO in a joint effort with UPMC. It was installed in part to monitor the fate of the large Acoustic Ice Tethered Profiler (AITP) ocean buoy its AITPs laser cloud sensor. For this reason it was placed close to (~ 3 meters) the AITP. It is also surrounded with 10-cm wide ablation stakes. The camera stands about 1.8 m above the April level of the ice surface. Owing to the wide-angle lenses used in the cameras, the AITP and the stakes are closer to the camera than they appear. The two web cameras are about 200 to 300-m apart with Web camera #2 looking to the right side of Web Camera #1 and Web Camera # 1 looking away from Web Camera #2.

In the July 26, 2013 Web Camera #2 images it is difficult to appreciate the size of the melt pond, but judging by the position of the small ridge beyond the far edge of the melt pond, we estimate the far shore of the pond is 20 to 50-m from Web Camera #2. It is about 40 cm deep at the AITP buoy. The AITP buoy, and subsequently Web Camera #2 were placed in a relatively low spot in the ice with a greater than average snow thickness, both of which contribute to the formation of the melt pond. Web Camera #1 and the surrounding buoys were placed on ice that was relatively thicker and had a slightly higher upper surface to avoid having them in melt ponds during the summer. This probably results in the Web Camera #1 giving a better representation of the general melt pond coverage of 20% to 50%.

FAQ – Frequently Asked Questions.

1) Is that the ocean melting through the ice or is it really a lake?

It is a small shallow lake resting on top of the ice. The water is almost completely fresh because it comes from melted snow and sea ice.

2) Why do the images from Web Cameras #1 and #2 look so different? Are they in different locations.

The two cameras are on the same major ice floe, but the wide-angle lenses of the cameras make things look much more distant than they actually are. Thus the highly variable character of the surface is not clear, especially for Web Camera 2, which is only giving images from inside the melt pond.

3) Are you alarmed at the appearance of the water near the North Pole?

No, melt ponds form every year, and considering Web Camera 1, the melt pond coverage at this location (the cameras and buoys have drifted to about 85°N, 5°W) looks pretty typical for this time of year and this location. Actually, we are more concerned about the extensive melt pond coverage that we have found on the Alaskan side of the Arctic Ocean as part of our Office of Naval Research-funded Seasonal Ice Zone Reconnaissance Surveys on U.S. Coast Guard Arctic Domain Awareness flights.

4) Is the appearance of the pond due to global warming?

No, not specifically. These melt ponds are a normal part of the seasonal cycle of the sea ice. With respect to global warming, we are more concerned when we see warm air temperatures in the winter that inhibit ice growth and the appearance of heat in the ocean that would melt the bottom surface of the ice.

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

2 Comments on “Camera allegedly showing the North Pole melting turns out to be approximately 300 miles to the South”

  1. Dougal Quixote July 30, 2013 at 2:14 pm #

    Reblogged this on windfarmaction and commented:
    Bad journalists don’t check their sources.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Camera allegedly showing the North Pole melting turns out to be approximately 300 miles to the South | ajmarciniak - July 29, 2013

    […] Camera allegedly showing the North Pole melting turns out to be approximately 300 miles to the South. […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: